Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Kaplan University charged with fraudulent practices

An article in today's New York Times explores the pressures on Kaplan University which is under investigation for misleading and exploiting students in several states at the same time that its parent company, The Washington Post Co., is increasingly relying on it for revenue and spending hundreds of thousands of dollars to defeat proposed federal regulation.

The entire article is linked here.

Below are key excerpts:

Kaplan is facing several legal challenges. The Florida attorney general is investigating eight for-profit colleges, including Kaplan, for alleged misrepresentation of financial aid and deceptive practices regarding recruitment, enrollment, accreditation, placement and graduation rates.

Kaplan is also facing several federal whistle-blower lawsuits whose accusations dovetail with the findings of an undercover federal investigation of the for-profit industry this summer, including video of high-pressure recruiting and unrealistic salary promises...

...This summer Senator Tom Harkin’s committee, in oversight hearings on the industry, watched undercover videos about high-pressure recruiting tactics that Kaplan and others used to sign up students.

Using hidden cameras, investigators from the
Government Accountability Office found deception or fraud at 15 for-profit colleges, including two Kaplan campuses.

The undercover videos showed Kaplan recruiters in Florida and California making false or questionable statements to prospective students — suggesting for example, that massage therapists earn $100 an hour, and that student loans need not be paid back.

...the bad publicity, and growing scrutiny, have taken their toll. Since its recent high last spring, Washington Post Company stock has dropped by more than a quarter. Other for-profit education companies, including Corinthian Colleges, in which the Post owns an 8 percent stake, fell even further...

...dozens of current and former Kaplan employees said the videos painted a representative picture.

“They are not outliers; they are in the middle of the field, the middle of the bell curve,” said William Wratten, a former Kaplan admissions adviser in Chicago, who resigned after a year and a half because he disagreed with company practices. “Maybe not the exact same activities, but the mind-set was the same: Do whatever it takes to get the sale, to keep your job.”

Mr. Wratten and other admissions representatives said they were trained to “emphasize that Kaplan is owned by The Washington Post, one of the best newspapers in the country, and that
Warren Buffett, and Bill Gates’s wife, Melinda Gates, were on our board of directors.”

...Four whistle-blower suits against Kaplan under the federal False Claims Act have been made public in the last few years, all making accusations that the company used deceptive practices in its quest for profits, including enrolling unqualified students and paying recruiters for each student enrolled, a practice forbidden by federal law.

In addition, the suits allege, Kaplan kept students on the books after they dropped out, inflated students’ grades and manipulated placement data to continue receiving financial aid.

Three of the suits, from Pittsburgh, Milwaukee and Miami, have been consolidated for trial in Miami. A fourth, from Las Vegas, is pending there.

But many current and former Kaplan employees and students — including those, like Mr. Wratten, not involved in the lawsuits — said in interviews that they believed the company was concerned most with getting students’ financial aid, and that Kaplan’s fast-growing revenues were based on recruiting students whose chances of succeeding were low.

They cite, for example, a training manual used by recruiters in Pittsburgh whose “profile” of Kaplan students listed markers like low self-esteem, reliance on public assistance, being fired, laid off, incarcerated, or physically or mentally abused.

Admissions advisers, past and present, say the pressure to recruit students leads to aggressive, and sometimes misleading, sales tactics.

Carlos Urquilla-Diaz, a former Kaplan instructor and administrator who is one of the Miami whistle-blowers, recalled a PowerPoint presentation showing African-American women who were raising two children by themselves as the company’s primary target.

Such women, Mr. Urquilla-Diaz said, were considered most likely to drop out before completing the program, leaving Kaplan with the aid money and no need to provide more services.

“The idea was, we’ll take anybody, and I mean anybody,” he said.

Victoria Gatsiopoulos, a former instructor and director of career services at a Kaplan College in Pittsburgh, said in her complaint that the school made promises to students of “how their lives will magically change” if they attended Kaplan classes.

One prospective student with financial difficulties, the complaint said, was promised in writing that “in five years she would have a job in a hospital, a big house in Florida, enough money to go to Disney World with her family and a new Lexus.”

Ms. Gatsiopoulos said Kaplan representatives routinely misled prospective students about the jobs they could get after graduation.

“One of our biggest programs was criminal justice,” she said. “Students who were recruited were led to believe that they could get into the C.I.A. or F.B.I. or Border Patrol or crime-scene investigation when they graduated, and earn $40-$50,000. But those jobs all require advanced training.”

In reality, Ms. Gatsiopoulos said, graduates would often get the same $8 to $9-an-hour security guard jobs they could have had without Kaplan training.

Ms. Gatsiopoulos’s complaint said that Kaplan also manipulated its reported placement rates so that a graduate employed in sales at Wal-Mart, for example, would be reported as working in accounting management, and that a telemarketer was reported as working in “business administration fashion merchandising.”

She also charges that Kaplan would raise instructors’ grades for students so they remained eligible for federal aid. Former Kaplan instructors not involved in the litigation made similar claims.

“More than once, when I refused to inflate a student’s grade, they went ahead and did it on their own,” Ms. Gatsiopoulos said...

Nine years after graduating from high school, Rebecca Masci, a single mother with four young children to support, enrolled in a surgical-technology program in 2004 at Kaplan/CCI in Broomall, Pa., to improve her job prospects.

She took out student loans, lined up her parents to baby-sit, and for three terms, excelled in her classes in anatomy, physiology and pharmacology. But to complete the fourth term and graduate, students need a placement to give her hands-on experience in an operating room. She did not get one.

“When I signed up, they sounded all positive, about plenty of placements, plenty of jobs,” said Ms. Masci, now 32 and with five children. “But after I finished the classes, they told me to go home and wait and they’d call when they found something. I was in limbo for more than a year.”

Eventually, she said, she was given one short placement, not enough to graduate. Now she has $14,000 of debt, but no surgical-technology certification.

“I’m further behind than I was before I started,” she said.

David Goodstein, who was the school’s director of education for nine months in 2006, said Ms. Masci’s experience was not uncommon.

Mr. Goodstein, who has filed a federal whistle-blower suit against Kaplan, said that although the school had not had enough placement opportunities for the surgical-technology program since 2002, it kept enrolling new students, taking their federal student aid, leaving them stranded without a placement and then dropping them from the program, which was phased out in 2007.

Mr. Goodstein’s lawsuit, filed four years ago, is under seal. But the Post Company’s securities filings disclosed an investigation of the program.

In the Las Vegas case, Charles Jajdelski, an admissions adviser at Kaplan’s Heritage College, said that while cleaning up after an October 2003, graduation ceremony, he found five boxes of diplomas sitting off to the side.

When he asked colleagues about the boxes, his complaint said, they told him they were for phantom students, kept on the books even though they never attended class. The more questions he asked, Mr. Jajdelski said, the more he was told to drop it.

“When I called Kaplan’s Western regional assistant director, he told me he knew all about it, I shouldn’t worry about it, and we didn’t ever need to have this conversation again,” Mr. Jajdelski said. “I called the human resources guy in Atlanta, and he said, ‘Charles, we need you to be a team player here.’ That knocked my socks off.”

Mr. Jajdelski reported the situation to the Education Department hot line in November 2003, his complaint said. He was fired weeks later. Kaplan officials said the company was unaware of Mr. Jajdelski’s accusations until his lawsuit was unsealed in 2008.

The broadest complaint against Kaplan is the one from Florida, in which the former dean of paralegal studies, Ben Wilcox, is one of three plaintiffs...

“They’ll tell you all sorts of terrible things about me,” Mr. Wilcox said, adding that Kaplan is intent on discrediting him because of his access to incriminating evidence. “But the bottom line is that Kaplan is a cold-hearted scam to make money by taking student loans from the government, and leaving students with debt that they’ll never be able to pay off.”

The other two plaintiffs, Mr. Urquilla-Diaz and Jude Gillespie, have both brought unsuccessful discrimination complaints against Kaplan.

Mr. Graham and Mr. Rosen emphasize that Kaplan has made important changes, including its new “Kaplan Commitment,” which allows students to enroll, risk free, for several weeks — thereby eliminating any incentive to recruit unqualified students.

During that period, either the student, or Kaplan, could decide that the program was not a good fit, and end the enrollment.

“Allowing students four or five weeks of conditional enrollment is quite a bold step,” Mr. Graham said. “Plainly, in the short term, it will lead to a shrinkage of enrollment, but we don’t know how much.”

Despite the lawsuits and negative attention, Kaplan remains lucrative. The Times said that Kaplan’s revenue in the last quarter was up 9 percent - to $743.3 million -- and that revenue from higher education is four times greater than revenue from test-prep, the company's original service.

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

Um, the GAO report didn’t cite Kaplan for fraud. It cited 4 other schools for fraud, but not Kaplan. Your headline is completely wrong and misleading and should be changed...if you care about accuracy, that is.

Anonymous said...

The Florida attorney general is investigating Kaplan for alleged misrepresentation of financial aid and deceptive practices regarding recruitment, enrollment, accreditation, placement and graduation rates.

Kaplan is also facing several federal whistle-blower lawsuits whose accusations dovetail with the findings of an undercover federal investigation of the for-profit industry this summer, including video of high-pressure recruiting and unrealistic salary promises.

Fraudulent practices accurately characterizes these accusations.

Anonymous said...

I'm going to formulate my own, personal project since you don't see any great jobs out there.

Can any person provide any tips or websites as to how to apply for government grant money to set up my own business? I have been looking on the web but each and every web site asks for money and I have already been told by the unemployment office to avoid the websites that request cash for grant info because they are rip-offs. I would be sincerely grateful for any advice.

Danny Weil said...

See my post article at Truthout.org at ut.org/neoliberalism-and-for-profit-predatory-educational-industry-you-cant-regulate-a-criminal-enterprise6

September 23, 2010

To contextualize the issue of the for-profit rpedatory colleges and the role of the neoliberal state in assuring the private ownership of the means of educational production.

Danny Weil

Anonymous said...

Getting the government on your side when you are facing a tough fight in court is a time honored technique in American business, and Kaplan and the for profit industry is no stranger to it. The usual approach is to equate the threat to Kaplan or the for profit industry with injury to society, (i.e. Americans are uneducated and need college degrees), then exaggerate the magnitude of the problem beyond recognition, (i.e. If we don't educate every American we will lose control as a world power) and then claim Kaplan University has the answer in the form of overpriced online education paid for by student loans. This rhetorical strategy makes it seem as if America is hanging on by a thread to its status as world economic power. All will be lost if it is not already, unless legislation is enacted to protect this altruistic industry and provide a college degree to everyone in America at tax payer expense.
The real problem ignored by the DOE is the conflict of interest between Kaplan, the for profit industry, elected officials, and the taxpayers. When the for profit industry is in trouble it has every incentive to use the political process to improve its chances of survival. Elected officials who see an opportunity to extract political contributions and other favors often are eager to help. Regulators at the DOE and accrediting bodies like the HLC are also willing participants insuring survival of the industry because their current positions and future ability to market themselves to the private sector are enhanced in this process. Elected officials and regulators know that there is a good chance the problem will get worse, but they don't care. By the time the industries problems become too visible to be ignored and the student loan debt crisis hits they will be long gone and a new generation of elected officials and regulators in place. And for this new generation the "crisis" will present additional opportunities to search for scape goats like Ben Wilcox and rescue the industry. These efforts are then used to convince tax payers who are left to pay the bill, that the government is on their side and something is being done to bring the guilty like Kaplan University to justice.
The for profit education industry in the United States is a highly sophisticated, diversified, activity that annually drains billions of dollars from Americas economy by unlawful conduct.
The question is, should the U.S. taxpayer continue to subsidize the for profit education industry, Kaplan University, and the Washington Post with government backed student loans when so much fraud goes unchecked by the Higher Learning Commission, the Department of Education , the DOJ and the courts?

Anonymous said...

Thiѕ is thе right wеb sitе for аnуbody whο
wіshes to finԁ out аbοut
this tοpic. You knοw so much іts almοѕt tough to argue ωіth уοu (not that I reаlly
wоuld wаnt to…HаHa). Υou certаinly put a brаnd nеw spin оn a topic that has been written about
for decaԁes. Eхcellent stuff, ϳust wοnderful!



mу weblog :: list of steroids
Also see my web page > pitbull on steroids

Anonymous said...

These are still mid range skills, and they improve upon other skills with additional destruction.
Rather than listen and hold court on all of the catastrophic predictions being blasted out into the Universe,
stop for a moment, and simply be with yourself.
You may want to use a carpenter's square to verify this.

Here is my web page: shitstorm kaufen

Anonymous said...

When you open it, music starts playing, and you do not have to do anything else but adjust the volume and close it when
you want it to be done. Pandora is free (ad-supported), but you
can buy an upgrade for no ads and other improvements.

With the Worldmate Nokia 5800 Xpress - Music application you can keep
track of the current times in up to five different cities worldwide at a
go.

Also visit my web-site; http://the-home-income-station.com/myjournal/groups/suggestions-within-internetradio-in-the-uk/

Anonymous said...

Your should see something similar to the illustration above.

The "Export to Facebook " plugin is simple to use and
allows you to export a single image or an album. Follow the installation process after the download is complete.


my blog :: http://www.moodlekurse.org/user/view.php?id=26583&course=1

Anonymous said...

Just wish to say your article is as astonishing.
The clearness in your post is just spectacular and i can think you are an
expert on this subject. Fine with your permission let me to take hold of your
feed to keep updated with impending post. Thank you one million
and please carry on the rewarding work.

my page - plans for wood

Anonymous said...

It's very simple to find out any topic on web as compared to textbooks, as I found this paragraph at this website.

Stop by my homepage free woodworking plans jewelry box