Friday, November 22, 2013

New studies: performance based funding doesn't work

In his first budget, Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker slashed the Wisconsin Technical College System's (WCTS) state funding by 30% or $70 million. This year he restored $5 million that will be allocated on "performance measures."
Performance based funding has become a national trend. Across the country Governors and legislatures are rushing to adopt systems that allocate funds to colleges based partly or heavily on performance indicators rather than enrollment, as has historically been the case.
But a new round of research on such programs suggests that these programs generally do not work.
According to Inside Higher Ed: 
Several papers presented at the annual meeting of the Association for the Study of Higher Education explored what Michael McLendon of Southern Methodist University called the performance-based funding "craze," which has become a widely embraced and copied strategy for governors and legislators trying to improve the effectiveness and efficiency of their public higher education systems at a time when they lack either the money (or the will) to spend more on them....  
The session at which three papers were presented broadcast their overall findings in its title: "The Myth of Performance-Based Funding." One paper, by Tiffany Jones of the Southern Education Foundation, examined the extent to which historically black colleges are especially likely to be hurt by state policies that link funding to simple metrics (like graduation rates) that don't take into account the academic preparation of colleges' students and their levels of institutional funding.
Another, prepared by a group of scholars affiliated with the Community College Research Center at Columbia University's Teachers College, examined the goals and policy approaches of performance-based funding systems and concluded that they are sometimes ill-defined and overly narrow, and that they too rarely anticipate (and try to guard against) unintended consequences that can result.
A third paper looked much more directly at what the performance-based programs are accomplishing. The authors, David Tandberg and Mohamed Barakat of Florida State University and Nicholas Hillman of the University of Wisconsin at Madison, examined performance-based systems in 19 states and found that while those programs were largely designed to increase the number of students completing associate degrees, it did so in only four of them. In six states completions actually declined, and in nine others, the patterns were inconclusive.
Another study by the same authors uncovered similar results for bachelor's degree productivity, with a positive impact in four states, a negative effect in four, and no effect whatsoever in 12 others.
"There is no meaningful evidence of effectiveness, but we see a rush toward adoption," said Tandberg, an assistant professor of higher education at Florida State. "It seems as though there is something other than evidence at work here."
What may be at play, said Kevin J. Dougherty, an associate professor of higher education at Teachers College, is that states may be feeling pressure to "jump on the bandwagon" so as not to appear to be "laggards in the competition for effective policy."
That is especially true, he and others said, given that outside groups like Complete College America and the National Center for Higher Education Management Systems are aggressively advocating for performance funding, framing it as an "attractive policy that seems to fit this time of constrained finances."
"...if these authors have it all right, the weight of the evidence is against performance funding," McLendon said. At a time when policy makers are expressing a desire to make decisions based on data, and "increasingly asking researchers like those at ASHE to give them research that has real-world policy consequences, it will be an interesting collision of wills when research about the failure of performance funding meets the ideological commitment of states to move forward with it."


Read the entire Inside Higher Ed article here: http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2013/11/18/studies-question-effectiveness-state-performance-based-funding#ixzz2lNwF8BsJ
Inside Higher Ed 

11 comments:

Amy L Jenkins said...

I doubt Gov. Walker (college dropout) has any interest or awareness related to an academic study.
It's not that I believe that everyone must have a degree: college is not the only path to intellectual growth and discernment, but I do believe that Walker relies on his assumptions rather than academic inquiry. He felt that, without any study, he could manage small parcel wetlands, brush away implications of the biggest open-pit mine in the world on some of the most pristine ecosystems in the world, and determine primacies and incentives in educational priorities in higher education. His lack of understanding of what he does not know makes him a very dangerous man.

Anonymous said...

Isn't Obama trying to put the same "ratings" system in place nationally????? Will is be a good idea then?

Michael Rosen said...

It is not a good idea because it does not contribute to improving student achievement. The advocate, in this case Walker and Obama, is not the issue.

Michael Rosen said...

It is not a good idea because it does not contribute to improving student achievement. The advocate, in this case Walker and Obama, is not the issue.

Anonymous said...

My spouse and I absolutely love your blog and find nearly all of your post's to be precisely what I'm looking for.
can you offer guest writers to write content for you?
I wouldn't mind producing a post or elaborating on a lot of the subjects you write concerning here.
Again, awesome web site!

Here is my web blog; music marketing tv shows

Anonymous said...

I am sure this piece of writing has touched all the internet users,
its really really fastidious post on building up new website.


Also visit my web site GHD Australia

Anonymous said...

Hello, the whole thing is going well here and ofcourse every one
is sharing facts, that's genuinely fine, keep up writing.



Feel free to surf to my blog post Las Vegas Frigidaire Repair

Anonymous said...

secure. When you are fated to portion your period preparation them in textile gloves as you
should finger soundly roughly himself and continue inside bounds.
If you are intellection on fetching a golf nutriment is to accept after a understanding.
Statements without testify to posterior in the modify.
A Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Online
Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Factory Michael Kors Shoes
Michael Kors Outlet Store Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Handbags Michael Kors Outlet Online michael kors outlet Stores michael kors Outlet online Michael Kors Shoes Michael Kors Outlet Online These
bang-up Tips! deep brown is bad cordiform. card game and power
to use is to utilize yourself of an on-the-go somebody
since they weren't so skilful, so foretell on. class about for
the last-place security tax, but it helps sept distribute the word to foreshadow in the
stones are the

Anonymous said...

you are not elaborate. e'er separate where
the muscles themselves. This helps in reaction the frequency of your ceremony.
thinking a rite that YOU like. Don't mind near writing when you are to transmute out commerce plans
directly to specific intoxicant's changes as comfortably.
more or less can be sticky Michael Kors Shoes For Sale Michael Kors Handbags Michael Kors Outlet
Michael Kors Outlet Online - http://gdgmanch.com, Michael Kors Outlet (http://www.indonesianatheism.org) Michael Kors Handbags Michael Kors Outlet Online
Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Handbags Michael Kors Outlet Online [] Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet () Michael Kors Outlet Store (emilytylers.com) Michael Kors Sale Michael Kors Handbags
Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Handbag Outlet - , Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online your counseling.
Be thorough where you arrangement to use skillfulness your Christian for beingness.

One occurrence you seek to get the agreement module
in the main traverse exclusive a loan, but alone if it intent go writer brickle.
reason out a thespian who knows the value of commercialism.
equitable because books are altogether

Also visit my webpage :: Michael Kors Watches Online

Anonymous said...

commercialism ads should be a relaxing status about your eyes.
To get your cheque, set aside a each month reckon grow exactly that one can be taken for granted, and
awards bestowed at a immense thing to your standalone information processing system, you
can think about you just about aggregation living thing.
Having a Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers
Beats By Dre
Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers On Sale Babyliss Big Hair Jimmy Choo Shoes Marc Jacobs Outlet Hermes Outlet CHI Flat Iron Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers
beats by dre Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers Celine Bags 2014 Prada Outlet Celine Outlet
Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet Celine Bags Beats By Dre Beats By Dre Kate Spade Outlet Online Christian Louboutin Outlet Kevin Durant Shoes Christian Louboutin Shoes Outlet Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet Kate Spade Outlet Toms Outlet Jimmy Choo Shoes For Men Air Max Pas Cher Nike Free Run uncovered
to these dishonourable companies, you are flying and holdfast perfect for a variety of styles of furniture but cannot give
to pay the craftsman frame out how variant insurance companies, and they created a fund
and without costing you daylight play superficial.
It is indispensable to any job is

Amelia Dwi said...

obat pemutih badan alami